5

This is prompted by a recent question about Drupal 8. I am not talking about the merits of this question in particular (I do agree that it was not a good fit for DA), but how do we want to handle good questions about Drupal 8?

The biggest problem that I see is that D8 is still rather immature (feature freeze will be EOY at the earliest), so there is a good chance that questions may be influenced by bugs and/or things that are still in flux.

I think we should discourage D8 questions, but don't actively burninate them.

Personally, I won't be taking a serious look at D8 until next year, so I won't be answering any D8 questions.

This is the only related question on Meta.SO that I could find, Is it okay to close questions about preview and beta products.

Thoughts?

  • 1
    +1 Totally agree. Nearly any question/answer about Drupal 8 would have to involve a fair amount of speculation, which would probably make it ineligible for this site anyway – Clive May 7 '12 at 0:38
5

Agreed, before there is at least a beta version or something, the only valid answer for non-developers is what I wrote in that question IMHO.

For developers, I think questions will be valid much earlier, e.g. starting around the feature freeze, there will be a huge amount of changes that could be asked and can be answered by then.

2

I think that the good questions about Drupal 8 are the ones that are still relevant when Drupal 8 will have its first official release. Generally, questions that involve speculation are not between them; they would not interest future readers, once Drupal comes out with a public release, nor would they interest any readers now, as there are few developers that need to get involved with developing modules for Drupal 8, now.

1

I completely agree. Drupal SA is a QA site, not a discussion site. The proper channels for discussing Drupal 8 development are listed in the Drupal 8 Initiatives page.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .