How can I ask this question in a way it does make sense? Since I wrote what I tried at all.
Additionally, the answer to my problem (which I included there) actually solved it.
- What'd be a good reason to downvote both the question AND the answer?
- What'd be a good reason to not force voters to write a mandatory comment to attach to their votes? Since votes reflect an opinion about the Q/A structure: why not to force users to justify their up/down vote? Specially for the down vote, since in the worst scenarios they restrict access to site functions.